Dear Sagebrush Sally,
Lately, it feels like free speech is on trial here in Tecopa—not in a courtroom, but on the streets, in businesses, and all over social media. Some folks are saying that speaking out, asking questions, or even reporting on public issues is “hurting the community,” and anyone who does it risks getting banned, harassed, or worse.
I’m worried that disagreement is being mistaken for destruction, and criticism for slander. And it’s starting to feel like certain people only believe in free speech when they’re the ones speaking. In a small town where relationships run deep and grudges run deeper, how do we defend the right to speak freely—even when it’s unpopular—without tearing each other apart?
— Silenced but Still Standing
Dear Silenced but Still Standing,
You’ve touched a nerve that runs deep through this dusty little town—and through every small community that’s ever tried to balance independence with accountability. The truth is, free speech is easy to praise when it flatters us. It’s when it challenges, criticizes, or makes us uncomfortable that its real value gets tested.
Now, let’s be clear: the First Amendment doesn’t come with a small-town exception. It protects speech that’s inconvenient, unpopular, even upsetting—so long as it’s not libelous, threatening, or inciting violence. That’s the bedrock of democracy, whether you’re on the floor of Congress or at the local brewery.
But I hear what you’re really asking: how do we practice that freedom here, in a place where everyone’s lives intertwine like creosote roots, and where one Facebook post can lead to a cold shoulder at the bathhouse? It’s not easy. The desert doesn’t come with a manual, and neither does community.
What I will say is this: disagreement is not destruction. Journalism is not slander. And criticism is not cruelty just because it makes someone uncomfortable. If our community can’t tolerate scrutiny, it’s not community—it’s control.
Yes, we must all speak with care. Words can hurt. But so can silence, especially when it means looking away from harm, corruption, or injustice. Uplifting a community doesn’t mean pretending it’s perfect. It means telling the truth, even when the truth makes folks squirm.
So what do you do when your right to speak runs up against someone’s desire not to be spoken about? You stand firm. You stay honest. You listen when it’s warranted, and you defend your voice when it’s under threat. Just remember to speak from purpose, not from pride. There’s power in clarity—and even more in compassion.
In Tecopa, we don’t have to agree. We don’t even have to like each other. But we do have to coexist. And if we can’t do that while respecting the right to speak freely, then we’ve got bigger problems than gossip or grit.
— Sagebrush Sally
Leave a Reply