Three Decades Later, Unofficial Water Test Used in Official County Process

Three Decades Later, Unofficial Water Test Used in Official County Process

A water quality report from 1995 is being used by Inyo County officials in 2025 as supporting documentation in their search for a new operator for Tecopa Hot Springs County Park — even though the report was never commissioned by the county.

The decades-old analysis was conducted by J. Edward Guilmette, an environmental consultant who happened to park his 31-foot mobile lab at the campground while conducting research on desert springs in the Death Valley region. During his stay, he collected a water sample from the pipe that supplies the men’s hot pool at the Tecopa facility — out of what he described as simple curiosity.

Back then, Guilmette’s portable lab could handle basic testing, but for more advanced chemical analysis, he sent the sample to National Testing Laboratories. The results — documented in Report #9720462 — painted a remarkably clean picture of the water at that time.

No dangerous chemicals like benzene, vinyl chloride, or other volatile organic compounds were detected. These substances, often linked to industrial pollution, were tested for in concentrations as low as parts per billion — and none were found. Similarly, no trihalomethanes — chemical byproducts sometimes formed when chlorine reacts with organic material — were present.

The water also tested free of harmful heavy metals such as lead, mercury, and cadmium. Only trace amounts of aluminum, barium, and sodium were detected, all well within safe levels. The pH measured a perfectly neutral 7.0, and the water was extremely low in total dissolved solids — a technical term that basically means there wasn’t much mineral buildup or contamination.

In terms of microbial safety, the lab found zero coliform bacteria in the sample, meaning the water showed no signs of fecal contamination or other biological hazards. Turbidity — or cloudiness — was also low, suggesting the water was clear and sediment-free.

Although Guilmette’s report was never part of any official county water monitoring program, it is now being used by Inyo County in its 2025 Request for Proposals (RFP) as evidence of water quality at the hot springs. The RFP seeks a new concessionaire to manage and operate Tecopa Hot Springs County Park — a popular and historic public facility located in the heart of the Amargosa Valley.

The county’s use of this private document raises some questions. The water sample was taken 30 years ago, under unknown maintenance conditions, and from a specific point in the system — the men’s hot pool inlet — which may or may not reflect the current quality of the source water or the infrastructure it flows through today. Moreover, Guilmette himself had asked the county back in 1995 to share their own historical test results, which suggests that his sampling was never intended to be definitive or comprehensive.

Still, the 1995 analysis offers a rare glimpse into the natural state of Tecopa’s geothermal waters before decades of additional use, facility wear, and environmental change. Whether it remains an accurate representation of conditions in 2025 is unclear.

As Inyo County weighs proposals from potential new operators, the question remains: will more recent and comprehensive water testing be conducted before a new concessionaire takes over — or will decisions be made based on a single water sample taken three decades ago, by a traveler just passing through?


Comments

5 responses to “Three Decades Later, Unofficial Water Test Used in Official County Process”

  1. Raymond Reed Avatar
    Raymond Reed

    This information from some random test in 1995 is questionable. in every manner that anything can be questioned. Cigarette smoking did not cause cancer in 1995 , at least not on the side of cigarette cartons. What does it say today – 25 years later?

    Oddly, in visiting with Jerry Olser, Environmental Health Director with Inyo County just a few months ago, I found out the following. In 1999, there were water tests performed by Inyo County for the county RV park. I was told the total coli form test failed. Since that test ( in 1999) every hot pool in Tecopa has been required to use bromine ( Br) or Chlorine ( Cl).

    Terry ( from Tecopa Hot Springs Resort) shared with me that Delights was not functionable in 1999 and had just been purchased by Steve Mcneill. This explains why the County of Inyo did not test the pools at Delightsfor total coli-form in 1999. Amy and Terry had just bought Tecopa Hot Springs Resort ( wasn’t called this name when they acquired it) and was in horrific condition, so no test there in 1999.

    I presently own ( Tecopa Palms Therapeutic Hot Springs Resort) which was known as the sugar shack in 1999, and did not, at this time, have a commercial use hot pool. Subsequently, a total coli-form test was NOTconducted here. The only test conducted by Inyo County, I was told, was at the County Pools in 1999.

    Several things I am going to respond to regarding the County’s claims. Why don’t the county have the county obtain new tests ? Here is why. The pools are contaminated, probably because they have algae around the peripheral. NO way does the county want yo have these pools tested because then its a current known fact. The County needs to get real.

    Mr. Olser shared with me that its virtually impossible to pass the “0” tolerance for total coli form test. It’s not just about fecal matter or pant base organisms, causing coli form – its about any coli form period.

    How did I eventually pass the tests ? Constant grief – CONSTANT.

    To test “0” for total coli-form I have learned by trial and error, that is takes constant inspecting the water in the pools after each person or people exit the private pool. I must ensure ( guarantee) that anyone entering the pools have thoroughly showered, with absolutely no makeup or bathing suits on including all shoes being left outside. NO dust or dirt from the bottom of sandals, shoes, or moccasins being tracked from the mats into the pool water. The body must be be washed from between ones toes up to and through their head and hair in the shower – using soap. Their body must be clean. Their body must be free of bacteria, dirt, and their mid sections clean. No swimming suits. EVER. Swimming suits carry body secretions from the front and the back.

    We have incorporated an authorization to enter “pool pass” that must be read and agreed to by the guest(s) before being allowed to enter the private hot pools where Gods Water From The Great deep is all natural. There is a sweat equity price for overseeing the cleanliness of a single pass through pool. It is labor intensive and stressful.

    When a guest or guests exits Gods Water From The Great Deep, I examine the pool with a high intensity flashlight. ( This can not be done at the county because each pool X 2 pools is constantly being used by entrants. The pools are seldom unoccupied. ) Water spoiling around in a brief holding area – will develop total coli form. If the guest(s) have left dead skin, oils, body secretions, or hair follicle’s all known as human contamination – the pool water will flunk the total coli – form test. Its the “total” in total coli -form that is the culprit.

    If the pool is contaminated when I inspect it, I must immediately drain the pool, sanitize the pool, and begin refilling it. After inspection, if I find it contaminated with floating stuff, dead skin, toe jam etc, I WILL immediately – without hesitation or reservation trespass this guest or guests off this property for failing to properly shower before entering the non contaminated water – to never return! I direct them to go where there is bromide or chlorine – There they can have their chemical absorption – party time- in contaminated water with long term “after” effects. Then I suggest that they be sure to do “their” due diligence on an EPA website about the long term effects on short term use of bromine or chlorine in water above 99 degrees F. ( Chlorine or bromine in Hot Tubs or Hot Pools) being absorbed into ones body creats mutagens. Mutagens cause cancer. ( google search: Can bromine in a hot tub cause mutagens )

    Then its ridiculous annoying to me – that people go to the borehole
    (published “locally by the gossipers” as the natural pool) which I have named the pee and poop pond for obvious reasons. Because in fact, this source has tested positive for total coli-form, high levels of bacteria, fugi infestation with not a single agency concerned about the contamination causing real life cancerous effects many months or even years after being in the “pee and poop – all natural” borehole. Micro organisms call the Tecopa borehole – “their home”.

    That said – when water from the great deep flows through a concrete tub, located on a business property that must comply with Federal, State, and County regulations everybody and every agency is involved. The best thing I can say about owning this business is like every business in California is seeing the sign that states you have just left California in ones rear view mirror.

    Then there is the County wanting some one – anyone to rebuild their park costing millions of dollars with no return on their investment.
    Millions spent on something they do not own. Who thinks of this stuff ? From a very famous movie – I recommend the following to any “zealot” that see’s this Inyo County Park refurbishment as their pot of gold. RUN FOREST RUN ! Its fools gold.

    If one sets the terms – then own the terms. The County sets the financial terms then the County complies with their requirements and refurbish the park. Its easier for the County to comply with their own requirements than any private business attempting to comply with Inyo County requirements, Inyo County inspectors, State Water Resource Requirements, (Housing Urban Development ( H.U.D.) requirements ( H.U.D. oversees RV parks) and numerous other agencies.

    ALL NATURAL –
    There is a price to pay for being “All Natural”. Not in monetary terms. But constant sweat equity. Fresh running water from 100’s of miles below the earths crust – single pass through pools -when combined with “contaminants” off of “one” body ( because of not thoroughly showering) will “flunk” a total coli-form test. Every time. EVERY TIME!

    Ask me how I know this ?

    The 1995 report from some guy, in a mobile lab working independently stated the water was 7.0. And 30 years later the county is using this. 7.0 pH is a joke for a mineral hot pool. 7.4 is the pH of a healthy persons saliva. Any natural occurring spring water will test at 7.4 pH. In a creek in Cherokee territory / Oklahoma or in a stream in Arkansas, in the Kern River in Bakersfield, in the Ocean or water at Shoshone. 7.4 to 8.0.

    As an example, Crystal Geyser and Figi drinking water will test every day at 7.4 pH. I show people the difference between sanitation engineered purified water ( from sewer reclamation facilities – which I have been a construction engineer on ) and Natural water – the pH of both – practically weekly here. Purified water is 6.5 pH – chlorinated. Natural spring water is 7.4 pH – no chemicals. Ocean water can be 7.4 to 8.0 pH. Crystal Geyser is a spring that flows underground from the Western Sierra mountain. I have been to their facility. It tests at 7.4 pH. Figi water originates from a deep aquifer in Figi and tests at 7.4 pH. I have taken numerous water samples from the Tecopa Kiosk to test for pH. It ‘s about 6.6 pH. Acidic. This said, my understanding is that the water at the Southern end of this area had less minerals and had a lower pH. This is “the why” the kiosk system was installed where it is.

    I read on Delights web site their water is 9.8. pH. I test the 3 pools here everyday for various reasons. The pH is a constant 9.8.

    Total coli-form is practically impossible to eliminate – the scale is “0”.
    I drain the pools every 3 to 4 hours. Yvonne or I spend no less than 30 minutes with each and every person showing them the pools, explaining the precautions in terms of heat induced disabilities and death, then we hand each of them a Pool Pass that has 12 conditions to obtain an entry permit. WE read through each condition with them. If they agree, they sign in agreement. If they don’t – they leave. Three other chlorinated or bromine pools to go to.

    In conclusion, the county pools will always test positive for total coli-form. Anyone can say anything at anytime. Lots of know nothing input. Spend 12 hours of your time every day, educating and inspecting and draining and sanitizing and monitoring one guest after another and another. This is the “constan” to obtain “0” total clori-form.

    The County will never pass the total coli-form test due to the constant “multi same sex use” pools at the county. As long as people enter it by the minute, sometimes 10 to 20 at a time, throughout the day, by the bus loads, with management not flushing and sanitizing the pools after each contamination – bromine will ALWAYS be required.

    NOTE: Yvonne, has stage IV C.L.L. The Apostle Paul states in Romans 8: 28 that ALL Things work together to the Glory of God …” Like spokes in a wheel, Gods water From The Great Deep is such a spoke for Yvonne —- the high pH combined with the high mineral content, eliminates the inflammatory pain in her bones

    Knowing what I know – Why would I ask Yvonne to enter water with bromine in it only to be diagnosed with kidney cancer or bladder cancer, or melanoma ?

    Owners in the other parks in Tecopa have their own private pools. Truly – What is good for “the goose” is not good for the “geese”.

    The County is fishing.
    They have the pole and the bait.
    Who will be the fish that will get “reeled” in ?

  2. Rayamond Reed Avatar
    Rayamond Reed

    To the author:
    “… painted a remarkably clean picture of the water at that time.”
    Really ?

    I think you purposely did not report on the serious consequences of Arsenic in the County’s 1995 water test. Many times higher than the 10 PPB threshold. The primary route in Tecopa is not drinking the water which has been diminished with the Kiosk; But, primarily absorption from hot water above 98.6F being absorbed into ones largest organ – skin. Over and over again.

    You made the 1995 Inyo County water test epic – with no need to worry about these elements, or chemicals as you described in your article. Certainly no need to worry about the water being Turbid or having higher than the P.E.L. exposure to Toluene .

    The primary finding, in the ’95 test, which was and is significant is Arsenic.
    You failed to mention that issue –
    The acceptable level, per O.S.H.A. is known as PEL, or Permissible Exposure Limits which is normally measured in Parts per million. But Arsenic is so toxic – it is measure in Parts Per Billion. ( PPB)

    To be precise 10 Parts per billion for Arsenic. is the PEL.
    0.05 is equivalent to 50 PPB which is 5 times the limit of permissible exposure limits of arsenic in water.

    0.01 PPM = 10 PPB.
    .05 ( see the test) = 50 PPB.

    The Arsenic levels in the county water is considered very high at 0.05 PPB.

    Well Ray we don’t drink the water ——
    I can hear it now !

    What about absorption( skin contact) in ones skin when the external temp is greater than 98.6F with the County pools maintaining temps from 104 F to 105F?

    The county should have made a note about this route of contamination. Is there a legal consequence ? Has anyone in Tecopa got cancer ?

    If so, how many people in Tecopa have linked their cancer to the Arsenic levels in the County pools – by soaking their body in the water 2 to 3 times a week ?

    ARSENIC:
    Arsenic is a naturally occurring element that is toxic to humans. Arsenic poisoning can occur through ingestion, inhalation, or skin contact, ( absorption). Both acute (short-term) and chronic (long-term) exposure to high levels of arsenic can have severe health consequences, affecting various bodily systems and potentially leading to death.
    Arsenic is a known carcinogen and has been linked to several types of cancer, including skin, lung, bladder, liver, kidney, and prostate cancer. It can cause skin lesions and other skin changes, cardiovascular disease, diabetes, and neurological issues.

    Yet, you collaborated the test in ’95 was not a problem.

    I quote, “No dangerous chemicals like benzene, vinyl chloride, or other volatile organic compounds were detected. These substances, often linked to industrial pollution, were tested for in concentrations as low as parts per billion — and none were found. Similarly, no trihalomethanes — chemical byproducts sometimes formed when chlorine reacts with organic material — were present.

    The water also tested free of harmful heavy metals such as lead, mercury, and cadmium. Only trace amounts of aluminum, barium, and sodium were detected, all well within safe levels.

    1. Nicole Brydson Avatar
      Nicole Brydson

      Thank you for your comment. You’ve raised an important issue regarding arsenic levels in the 1995 water test and its potential health impacts, especially considering the absorption route through skin contact during hot spring soaks.
      To help clarify and further investigate the concerns you’ve mentioned, could you please provide any documentation or records of Tecopa water testing in your possession, including the 1999 Inyo County water tests that you are referring to, particularly more recent ones or those showing arsenic levels significantly higher than the acceptable threshold? Having access to that data would greatly aid in assessing the situation more in depth. I believe you have my email.

      1. Raymond Reed Avatar
        Raymond Reed

        I appreciate your questions. I prefer replying for the benefit of others – especially for those that are unaware, and those that are debaters, the stone throwers. The 1995 test ( that you have attached in your article) reports arsenic. See Arsenic hidden away on Page 3 in your article. Kind of hidden – I think. The information in the 1999 test by Inyo County was shared by Jerry Olser to my attorney and I. The 1999 test conducted “specifically” by the Environmental Health department in Inyo County for the County Pools in Tecopa remains in their possession. I suggest you contact Mr. Olser and ask him for the data regarding the 1999 sample test that reported total coli form failing.

        Decontamination: ( R.O.E.) When one is “in” the Radius Of Exposure or in the exposure itself, and is subsequently exposed, decontamination is imminently important. The key word is “imminently” . At Tecopa Palms Therapeutic Hot Springs Resort, I strongly urge every person, (Yvonne and I do this) when soaking in Gods Water From the Great deep to drink 8 ounces of water about 5 minutes before exiting the hot mineral water – to flush OUT toxins – and to drink a bottle of water immediately after exiting the pool house to continue to sweat “OUT” toxins. I also recommend each “soaker” to take a shower after exiting the pool to thoroughly was off their their skin and pores.

        With better than 40% of our general population being diagnosed with cancer in the U.S. today and yet a higher percentage for those over the age of 50, one should be inquisitive enough to ask why ? Absorbing minerals is very beneficial to ones skeleton and muscular body. As an example when Yvonne’s skeleton is very painful, soaking for 3 minutes eliminates “ALL” her pain. Then comes drinking fresh ” cool not cold” water to flush out the toxins from her skin using perspiration as the removal vehicle. Flushing is the act of washing anything out of ones eyes or off ones body to decontaminate, and is very often seen in a Material Safety Data Sheet or known today as a Safety Data Sheet.

        Drinking “cool not cold” water about 3 to 5 minutes before exiting the pool, then showering, and drinking more “cool not cold” water and continuing to perspire – is a pro-active method to eliminate the accumulative storage of Arsenic in ones body known as T.L.V. Threshold Limit Value.

        The report the County used to indoctrinate the “fish hook biter” in investing millions into the Countys park, from 1995 listing 2 pages of line item elements, minerals etc, in my opinion, put the “A” on the last page for a reason. A for Arsenic. What is the Counties “action plan” to prevent arsenic toxicity than can cause child birth issues to cancer ? I think I have heard it at least a million times. Well – this is a transient community and a transient use pool. In other words when one gets cancer 5 years from now – from whence did it originate ? Sounds good – I guess – but not an action plan and certainly is not a protective plan for the locals.

        Thanks for your question. Ray Reed, Certified Mine Safety Professional, USA #315 ( Retired)

        1. Nicole Brydson Avatar
          Nicole Brydson

          Thanks, Ray — I appreciate you sharing your thoughts publicly. I’ve requested those records from Inyo County and will report on them as soon as they arrive. I’m very interested in this topic: have you ever tested the water composition at your resort? My understanding is that all of the hot springs draw from the same aquifer, and I’d be curious to learn more. I’m sorry to hear about Yvonne’s illness. I also experienced illness at one point, and the waters of Tecopa played an important role in my recovery, so I’m committed to ensuring this resource is used with care and responsibility.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Amargosa Conservancy Amargosa River Amargosa vole Ash Meadows BLM Borehole Spring Center for Biological Diversity Charleston View Death Valley Brewing Death Valley Hot Springs Death Valley National Park Delight's Hot Springs Resort Desert Life Dumont Dunes Flippin-Hamricks Free Speech Friends of the Amargosa Basin Furnace Creek Inyo County Inyo County Board of Supervisors Inyo County Sheriff Lake Tecopa Airbnb Lance Hamrick Local Business Local Economy Mining Mojave Desert Patrick Donnelly RFP Road Trip Robin Flinchum Shoshone Shoshone Museum SIFPD Southern California Edison Susan Sorrells TecopaFest Tecopa Hot Springs Campground Tecopa Hot Springs Conservancy Tecopa Local Tecopa Mines Tecopa Palms Tecopa Takeover Tourism Will Wadelton