Sagebrush Sally: Scrutiny Builds Stronger Communities

Dear Sagebrush Sally,

As you’re surely aware, the winds have been stirring up a bit of drama around town lately. Some folks around here say that asking tough questions or reporting on local issues just causes trouble—and that if you really care about the community, you’ll stay quiet and keep the peace. Even worse, they say it’s not journalism. But I’ve always believed that scrutiny and transparency are part of what keeps a town healthy, especially one as small and interconnected as ours.

Why is it that in small towns, people can get so defensive when someone shines a light on what’s really going on? And how do we help folks understand that local journalism and accountability aren’t attacks—they’re acts of care?

— Curious, Not Combative

Dear Curious, Not Combative,

You’ve struck a nerve as old as the desert hills. In small towns like Tecopa, where everybody’s business feels like everybody’s business, asking questions—especially the uncomfortable kind—can feel like throwing a rock into still water. Some folks call it trouble. I call it necessary.

Here’s the truth: real community isn’t about avoiding tension—it’s about holding space for it, working through it, and coming out stronger on the other side. Scrutiny, accountability, and yes, even criticism, are signs that people care enough to pay attention. If no one’s asking questions, that’s when you should really start to worry.

Now, I understand the defensiveness. In a small town, reputation is currency. It can feel like one bad headline, one open record request, or one Facebook post might stain a name for good. But the answer to that isn’t silence—it’s clarity. Local journalism isn’t here to ruin lives; it’s here to remind us that no one is above being asked to explain themselves when the public’s interest is at stake. That includes the county, the campground operator, the business owner, and yes, even your neighbor who’s been here “since before the hot springs had a roof.”

Journalism isn’t gossip—it’s a service. It shines a light where power might otherwise hide in the shadows. And in a town without much government, where decisions are made by the few but affect the many, we need more light, not less. Especially when big money, outside developers, or failing infrastructure come into play.

Dismissing something as “not journalism” just because it makes you uncomfortable doesn’t make it true—and most folks tossing around that claim aren’t exactly qualified to define journalism in the first place. And like it or not, even tabloids and gossip rags fall under the umbrella of protected speech—because the First Amendment doesn’t just cover polite conversation, it covers the messy, uncomfortable, and inconvenient too.

So to those who say “keep quiet to keep the peace,” I say: peace without accountability isn’t peace—it’s permission. Permission to let things slide, to let people get hurt, to let the truth stay buried under desert dust. Folks who’d rather keep things to the rumor mill and run the journalists out of town aren’t protecting the community—they’re protecting their comfort, their control, or their secrets.

If you’re asking honest questions and documenting facts you’re not causing harm. You’re tending to the health of the community, like watering a stubborn patch of wildflowers in the July sun.

Remember though, giving people a chance to speak for themselves—even when it’s messy—works best if they actually show up to speak; if you don’t engage with journalists, don’t be surprised when your perspective doesn’t make it into the story.

Keep asking. Keep caring. Tecopa needs scrutiny far more than it needs another rumor whispered over a beer and called truth.

Sagebrush Sally

Name
Not required if you would like to remain anonymous.
Email
Only necessary if you would like us to follow up with you.
This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.


Comments

One response to “Sagebrush Sally: Scrutiny Builds Stronger Communities”

  1. Raymond Reed Avatar
    Raymond Reed

    Gossipers and 1st Amendment protection.
    1st amendment has an umbrella but it also has some holes in that umbrella.

    BUSINESS DEFAMATION
    Business defamation occurs when false statements are made about a company that harm its reputation and potentially its financial standing.

    This can significantly impact a business through both libel (written defamation) and slander (spoken defamation).

    Key elements of a business defamation claim
    To successfully pursue a claim, a business generally needs to establish the following:

    False statement: A demonstrably false statement of fact must have been made about the business, its products, or services. This cannot be a mere opinion or criticism.

    Publication to a third party: The false statement must have been communicated to at least one person other than the business itself.

    Fault: The defendant must have been at fault for the publication of the statement. This fault can be either:

    Negligence: For private businesses, this means the defendant failed to exercise reasonable care in verifying the truth of the statement before publishing it.

    Actual Malice: For businesses considered “public figures,” this means the defendant knew the statement was false or acted with reckless disregard for its truth or falsity.

    Harm to reputation and provable damages: The business must demonstrate that the defamatory statement caused actual harm to its reputation, resulting in quantifiable losses. This typically involves economic harm like lost sales, canceled contracts, or decreased valuation, as opposed to emotional distress claimed in individual defamation cases.

    Examples of business defamation
    Business defamation can manifest in various ways:

    False online reviews: A customer leaving a fabricated review accusing a restaurant of unsanitary practices.

    Competitor defamation: A rival business spreading rumors that a company is on the verge of bankruptcy.

    Defamation by employees or former employees: A disgruntled ex-employee posting false allegations about the workplace environment or management on social media or job sites.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Amargosa Basin National Monument Amargosa Conservancy Amargosa River Amargosa vole Ash Meadows BLM Borehole Spring Caltrans Center for Biological Diversity Charleston View Death Valley Brewing Death Valley National Park Delight's Hot Springs Resort Desert Life Dumont Dunes Fire Firefighters Free Speech Friends of the Amargosa Basin Furnace Creek Inyo County Inyo County Board of Supervisors Inyo County Sheriff Inyo County Sheriff's Office Local Business Local Economy Matt Kingsley Mining Mojave Desert Patrick Donnelly RFP Road Trip Shoshone Shoshone Museum SIFPD Southern California Edison Susan Sorrells Tecopa Hot Springs Campground Tecopa Hot Springs Conservancy Tecopa Mines Tecopa Palms Tourism Villa Anita Will Wadelton Wonderhussy